Blog

Articles and videos to help you be a better business owner

Stop Overthinking

Introduction: The Problem with Overthinking

As a business owner, making the right decisions is crucial. However, when analysis turns into paralysis, progress grinds to a halt. Overthinking can make you doubt your choices, delay action, and ultimately, hinder business growth. Instead of moving forward, you find yourself stuck in a cycle of second-guessing. To break free you have to stop overthinking.

But how do you recognise the problem with overthinking before it becomes a bottleneck? More importantly, how do you find a balance between strategic thinking and decisive action? In this post, we’ll explore practical strategies to shift from thinking to doing, helping you lead your business with confidence.

Signs You May Be Overthinking Things

Before tackling overthinking, it’s essential to recognise when it’s happening. Here are a few red flags:

  • Endless research with no action: You spend hours gathering information but never make a move.
  • Fear of failure keeps you stuck: You delay decisions because you’re afraid of making the wrong choice.
  • You seek constant reassurance: You rely on feedback from too many people, causing decision fatigue.
  • Reluctance to delegate: You micromanage or hold back delegating because you fear no one else can do the job as well as you.
  • You overanalyse past mistakes: Instead of learning and moving forward, you dwell on what went wrong.
  • You set unrealistic expectations: You want perfection. You set extremely high standards for yourself and others.

If any of these sound familiar, it’s time to break free from the overthinking trap.

1. Work the Problem, Not the Fear

When faced with a challenge, it’s easy to spiral into worst-case scenarios. However, true problem-solvers, like NASA’s legendary flight director Gene Kranz, knew that focusing on solutions—not panic—was the key to success. During the Apollo 13 crisis, he famously told his team:

“Let’s work the problem, people. Let’s not make things worse by guessing.”

This mindset is just as valuable today, whether you’re leading a business or navigating daily decisions.

How to Work the Problem Effectively:

  • Focus on Solutions, Not Problems: Instead of dwelling on what could go wrong, shift your attention to potential fixes and positive outcomes.
  • Challenge Negative Thoughts: Acknowledge when your thoughts lean toward worst-case scenarios. Instead, reframe them into constructive, action-oriented alternatives.
  • Avoid Wasting Time on Fear: The more you obsess over what might go wrong, the more you delay progress. Direct that energy into creating a step-by-step plan.

By adopting a “work the problem” approach, you stay in control, make better decisions, and turn obstacles into opportunities.

2. Take a Step Back: Change Your Approach

Sometimes, the harder you try to stop overthinking, the stronger those thoughts become. Instead of forcing your mind to stay fixated on a problem, consider shifting your approach.

Here’s how you can break the cycle of overthinking:

  • Change Your Activity: If you’re stuck in a loop, do something completely different. A short distraction can help reset your brain and clear mental clutter.
  • Make Time for Reflection: Rather than endlessly stewing on a problem, set aside 15 minutes to reflect on the bigger picture. This allows for deeper insights without getting lost in negativity.
  • Step Back for a Fresh Perspective: Taking a break from a tough decision can help you return to it with renewed clarity and focus.

By allowing yourself the space to reset, you’ll be better equipped to tackle challenges with a clearer, more productive mindset.

3. Reprogramme the Voice in Your Head

Overthinking often comes from self-doubt or negative internal dialogue. To combat this, you need to reprogramme the voice in your head with constructive thought patterns.

  • Use Positive Affirmations: Shift your mindset by reinforcing beliefs like, “I am capable of making the best decision with the information I have.”
  • Practice Mindfulness: Recognise when you’re spiralling into over analysis and refocus on solutions rather than problems.
  • Limit Decision Fatigue: Reduce the number of daily decisions by automating repetitive tasks or delegating responsibilities.

By training your brain to trust your instincts, you’ll develop more confidence in taking action.

4. Planning to Overcome Uncertainty

Business decisions come with uncertainty, but planning can help mitigate the fear of the unknown. Here’s how you can plan effectively without falling into analysis paralysis:

  1. Set Clear Decision-Making Criteria: Establish a framework for making choices based on key priorities (e.g., budget, timeline, business goals).
  2. Use the 80/20 Rule: Focus on the 20% of decisions that will yield 80% of the impact. Avoid perfectionism in minor choices.
  3. Set a Deadline for Decisions: Give yourself a specific time frame to research and decide. If you spend too much time weighing options, you’re not planning—you’re hesitating.

The key is to plan with action in mind, not just to avoid making mistakes.

5. Beware the Dip When Implementing Change

When you finally take action, beware the dip—the moment when initial excitement wears off, and you start questioning whether you made the right move.

Many business owners retreat into overthinking when they hit this rough patch, reversing their decisions or constantly tweaking strategies without giving them time to work. Instead, commit to seeing things through by:

  • Tracking progress objectively: Use metrics rather than emotions to assess results.
  • Giving your strategy time to work: Change takes time—avoid making snap judgments.
  • Learning from small failures: Adjust and pivot, but don’t let minor setbacks drive you back into inaction.

The key to success is pushing past the discomfort of uncertainty and staying committed to your goals.

6. Take the First Step

Overthinking keeps you stuck. The only way to move forward is to take the first step—even if it’s imperfect. Start small:

  • Instead of over-researching, make a decision with the best available information.
  • Instead of waiting for the perfect time, act now and adjust as needed.
  • Instead of fearing mistakes, treat them as learning opportunities.

The more you practice acting decisively, the easier it becomes to find a balance between thinking and doing.

Conclusion: Think Smart, Act Fast

In business, overthinking can be as damaging as reckless decision-making. The secret to success lies in smart thinking and timely action. Recognise the signs of overthinking, right-size the problem, develop a structured plan, reprogramme self-doubt, and push past initial resistance.

Remember, progress comes from doing, not just thinking. So, what’s one decision you’ve been overanalysing? Take action on it today.

If you’re still struggling with overthinking – or you’d simply like to fast track your way to success, I invite you to book 15 minutes on my calendar to talk about business coaching at www.TimeWithShane.com. And that really is taking action!!